ForgotPassword?
Sign Up
Search this Topic:
Forum Jump
Posts: 2850
08/21/12 6:07 AM
Posts: 1286
08/21/12 11:04 AM
TSMB Supporter
Posts: 1417
08/21/12 11:48 AM
08/22/12 4:44 AM
Posts: 325
08/22/12 4:20 PM
Posts: 173
08/22/12 4:36 PM
Posts: 9005
08/22/12 7:02 PM
08/22/12 9:44 PM
Posts: 3116
08/23/12 6:34 AM
Posts: 127
08/23/12 6:44 AM
alex black wrote:There, I said it. The ultimate Heresy on TSMB. The quality of the tinnitus signal makes a huge difference. Saying this in the past has resulted in people telling me, both in public posts and in private messages, to get the hell off of this board.
08/23/12 10:10 AM
smn wrote:I don't know anybody on this board who has said that the quality of the sound is irrelevant to habituation.This is a great thread that Greg created, and I don't mean to veer from his original intent of having a thread in which people relate what worked for them. This isn't the best place to get into a discussion on old arguments, or on my particular condition - but I'd like to respond - but I recommend that anyone who wisely wants to just read about what has worked for other people should just skip this tangent.smn, you were in the middle of that scrum (the "loudness matters" thread). If you don't recall people saying with conviction that the T signal is irrelevant, I'm genuinely concerned for your memory. Several people asserted that, vehemently and dogmatically - and a number of people disagreed with them, and then all hell broke loose - 600 posts worth. It was insane. I certainly do not feel that way. Habituation is all about reaction. If the quality of your tinnitus affects your reaction, then that is an additional barrier to be overcome. As I understand it, Alex, your other conditions make it difficult to take advantage of the sound-based strategies that would be recommended by most knowledgeable tinnitus clinicians in a case such as yours.Difficult, yes, but not impossible. I can't wear in-ear devices, but I can do any sound therapy by having sounds created and played through a stereo at home, and can listen to it 8 hours a day (or 16 if during sleep as well).I can't listen to music, but I can listen to any white noise (I do now - at least 16 hours a day -but it's not white noise that either masks my tinnitus, or "interferes" with it, as I understand white noise should do in TRT). Masking has proven difficult for an odd reason. My one problematic sound is intermittent, and when it comes on, it is a combinatino of a high-frequency hissing noise (which is what I used to have 24/7 as part of my original tinnitus symphony - and which is no problem at all), and the problematic sound of chalk down a blackboard. When I mask it, once i stop listening to the maksing high-frequency white noise, I get a huge amount of residual inhibition of the non-problematic hissing noise, which leaves only the problematic sound of "chalk down a blackboard", which, by itself without the hissing noise, is much MUCH more annoying. It turns out that the hissing noise is acting almost like a WNG would in TRT!! It "interferes" with the one problematic sound - I can still hear that sound, but the hissing noise partially masks it.Sooo... masking will only work if I do it constantly while this intermittent sound is on (usually 2 out of every 3 days).TRT is still an option -but not with an in-ear WNG - only with an external sound which further "interferes" with my one problematic sound. I was going to start a thread at some point on "Self-administerd TRT" and ask questions about how to best set the external "interfering" sound. I can get any white noise frequency band created to play through my stereo, so this is doable. Since it's come up in this conversation, I guess I can pose that question now. Any thoughts on that?
Posts: 9885
08/23/12 2:35 PM
08/23/12 3:23 PM
llilly wrote:Can you point to a public post where you were told to "get the hell off this board"? It would be easy for you to search the archive for it because you know the author and content, alex black.
08/23/12 7:29 PM
Posts: 410
08/24/12 4:40 AM
Share This